true crimeMorbid Index Editorial2026-11-11Nashville police identified Toni L. Gordon through genetic genealogy. Sheila Cummings, the other woman found in 1987, was identified by a family DNA match.

News

Nashville Police Identify Toni L. Gordon in the Charlotte Avenue Case

Nashville police identified Toni L. Gordon through genetic genealogy. Sheila Cummings, the other woman found in 1987, was identified by a family DNA match.

Topics: Toni L. Gordon, Sheila Cummings, Nashville, Forensic Identification

Morbid Index

Metro Nashville Police identified Toni L. Gordon, a 31-year-old Nashville woman, as the second of two women found at a Charlotte Avenue home in 1987. Police announced her name on November 9, 2026, after identifying her through forensic genetic genealogy and notifying her family. The other woman, Sheila Cummings, was identified in July 2025.

The identifications came decades after the murder convictions. James Shaffer, who rented the home where the women were found, confessed after the discovery, according to police. He received two life sentences and died in prison in 2004. Police believe the women were killed about two years before they were found.

How Sheila Cummings was identified in 2025

Cummings was 23 and from Elgin, Illinois. Police said both women’s remains were exhumed in January 2025 for new forensic testing. Two days before investigators collected DNA samples, a woman who had read about the case online called the Cold Case Unit. She said her mother had been missing since 1984. Police obtained DNA samples from Cummings’s daughters and announced a confirmed match on July 3. See also JonBenét Ramsey DNA: Why Police Are Cautious About New Tests.

How Toni L. Gordon was identified in 2026

While investigators were still looking for Gordon’s name, police circulated a forensic rendering in April 2025. Shaffer had referred to her as “Lil’ Bit.” Her family believed she had moved to another state and fallen out of contact, police said.

Forensic genetic genealogy can help investigators look for possible relatives through DNA and use genealogical records to follow those leads. Nashville police credited several agencies and laboratories with helping to identify the women. The November release did not specify which genealogical records or final comparison established Gordon’s identity. The confirmed DNA match to Cummings’s daughters was a separate finding. See also Derek Identified in Toronto's 1992 Unidentified Case.

For a comparison, the identification of Willie Blanton Mills shows how a genetic genealogy lead can point investigators to a family and a fingerprint comparison can then confirm a name.

Sources & further reading